Free Consultation. No Fees Until You Collect. Call 24 Hours a Day 1-800-4-RIGHTS

Minnesota Offices

Serving all of Minnesota Call 1-800-4-RIGHTS

If you’re recovering, we’ll come to you. Or we’ll set up a meeting at one of our convenient office locations:

  • Minneapolis, Minnesota612-333-4500
  • Lakeville, Minnesota952-469-2288
  • Duluth, Minnesota218-722-6848
  • AUTO
    ACCIDENTS

    • Minnesota Accidents
      • Minnesota Car Accidents
      • Minnesota Motorcycle Accidents
      • Minnesota SUV Rollover Accidents
      • Minnesota Drunk Driving Accidents
      • Minnesota Semi-Truck Accidents
      • Minnesota Pedestrian Accidents
      • Minnesota Bicycle Accidents
      • Minnesota Bus Accidents
    • Minneapolis Accidents
      • Minneapolis Car Accidents
      • Minneapolis Motorcycle Accidents
      • Minneapolis SUV Rollover Accidents
      • Minneapolis Drunk Driving Accidents
      • Minneapolis Semi-Truck Accidents
      • Minneapolis Pedestrian Accidents
      • Minneapolis Bicycle Accidents
      • Minneapolis Bus Accidents
    • Lakeville Accidents
      • Lakeville Car Accidents
      • Lakeville Motorcycle Accidents
      • Lakeville SUV Rollover Accidents
      • Lakeville Drunk Driving Accidents
      • Lakeville Semi-Truck Accidents
      • Lakeville Pedestrian Accidents
      • Lakeville Bicycle Accidents
      • Lakeville Bus Accidents
    • Duluth Accidents
      • Duluth Car Accident
      • Duluth Motorcycle Accidents
      • Duluth SUV Rollover Accidents
      • Duluth Drunk Driving Accidents
      • Duluth Semi-Truck Accidents
      • Duluth Pedestrian Accidents
      • Duluth Bicycle Accidents
      • Duluth Bus Accidents
  • Personal
    Injury

    • Personal Injury Overview
    • ATV Accidents
    • Boating Accidents
    • Civil Rights Violations
    • Construction Accidents
    • Dog Bites
    • Product Liability
    • Slip, Trip and Fall
    • Snowmobile Accidents
    • Train Accidents
    • Wrongful Death Accidents
    • Sexual Assault and Abuse
    • Medical Malpractice
    • Birth Injuries
    • Hospital Negligence
    • Medication Errors
    • Misdiagnosis
    • Nursing Home Negligence
    • Surgical Complications
  • Workers
    Comp

    • Workers Compensation Overview
    • Construction Accidents
    • Minnesota Work Comp Law Update
    • Mesothelioma and Asbestos
    • Occupational Diseases
    • Third Party Claims
    • Workers' Compensation At A Glance
  • Verdicts &
    Settlements

  • Client
    Case Studies

  • Our
    Attorneys

    • George J. Berens
    • Eric W. Beyer
    • Robert T. Brabbit
    • James P. Carey
    • Nick Carey
    • Paul K. Downes
    • Robert J. Hauer Jr.
    • Susan M. Holden
    • Arthur C. Kosieradzki
    • Jeffrey M. Montpetit
    • Marcia K. Miller
    • Mark G. Olive
    • Michael F. Scully
    • Harry A. Sieben, Jr.
    • Jeffrey S. Sieben
    • Matthew E. Steinbrink
    • Cory P. Whalen
    • Featured Pages:
    • Meet Our Auto Accident Attorneys
    • Meet Our Personal Injury Attorneys
    • Meet Our Medical Malpractice Attorneys
    • Meet Our Workers' Compensation Attorneys
  • YOUR RIGHTS
    BLOG

Close
  • Home
  • Case Studies
  • Bill’s Story – “$4,000 Offer Was Ridiculous”

Bill’s Story – “$4,000 Offer Was Ridiculous”

It was just a couple of days before Christmas, so I went out to pick up a couple more presents. I’m sitting at a stoplight with four other cars, waiting to cross Highway 55. All of a sudden, there’s a boom when a lady runs into the back of my car. A couple of days later, my neck started bugging me.

But it was Christmas, you know, and I just put some ice on it, hoping it would get better. When it didn’t, I finally went to urgent care, where they told me it was whiplash from the accident. Since then, I’ve had fusion surgery and tons of aggressive therapy.

The other driver’s situation seemed shady to me, so I decided to get an attorney. I found Paul and SiebenCarey online, met with him, and haven’t looked back since. He, Lisa, and Alex were just fantastic. Anytime I had a question, they would return my calls right away. My previous experience with a work comp attorney at another firm was completely the opposite. I’d call, and the secretary would say hang on a second, then get back on and tell me he’s not in the office today. That happened a lot.

Anyhow, Paul really showed his stuff after the insurance company offered $4,000 to settle the claim, which was ridiculous. State Farm flew in this expert witness who was supposed to show I couldn’t have been hurt badly based on the property damage, the speed of the other car, and so on. Paul made this guy look foolish for missing major evidence proving my case. I was really impressed.

What aggravated me about the whole experience is that the other side makes you feel like the bad guy. You’re just sitting at a stoplight after picking up a couple of Christmas presents, doing nothing wrong. Then you get hit and go through all this pain and medical care. But they put the microscope on you instead of the person who caused the crash.

Well, we turned the tables on them with Paul and SiebenCarey. They tried to play hardball on the negotiation, but Paul ate ‘em up, and we eventually settled for $150,000. Again, I couldn’t be happier with Paul and his team. I’d give their phone number to anyone who needs a personal injury or workers’ comp attorney. They’re fantastic.

– Bill S.

Paul K. Downes

“My career is focused on helping people and representing them to the best of my ability.”
paul.downes@knowyourrights.com
Phone: 612-333-9774
  • Profile Home
  • Client Case Studies:
  • Bill's Story

  • Mary Jane's Story

  • A Motorcycle Driver's Story

START A CASE EVALUATION TODAY

Verdicts and Settlements

HUNDREDS OF MILLIONS

recovered for our clients

See recent verdicts and settlements

About Us

  • Award Winning Attorneys
  • Certified Investigators
  • Client Case Studies
  • Community Service
  • Minnesota Statute of Limitations
  • Verdicts and Settlements

Next step

Tell us about your case...

GET YOUR FREE CASE REVIEW

FREE Know Your Rights Kit

Get immediate access to the checklists, worksheets, and overviews you need if you or someone you care about is injured.

ACCESS NOW

Client Reviews

out of 243 reviews
  • Ashlyn Wall
    They were able to work with me while I was away for school and much appreciated the help. I would highly recommend them!
  • Bob Levin
    I was very pleased with John and the services he provided. I would highly recommend him.
  • Heather Jeffers
  • Christopher Revord
    They took all the rights steps to settling my case fast!
  • Tara Papacek
    Great experience on a long and complicated case which ended with an excellent outcome.
  • St. Paul Local 12
    Thanks for everything, your experience paid off BIG!!!
  • Jesse Bukal
    In need of a personal injury attorney? Well you're if you're reading this you're in the right place. You'd be hard pressed to find more competent atto ...See full review
  • Ross Baumgartner
    I was left in a very tough position. I was denied everything from an insurer after a terrible automobile accident. After contacting SiebenCarey not on ...See full review
SEE CLIENT CASE STUDIES

Award Winning Know Your Rights Attorneys

Best Lawyers in America

2025 Best Lawyers in America©

Also awarded in:
2025, 2024, 2023, 2022, 2021, 2020, 2019, 2018, 2017, 2016, 2015, 2014, 2013, 2012, 2011, 2010, 2009, 2008.

Attorneys of the Year

5 of our attorneys have been recognized as Attorneys of the Year

2025 Best Law Firms®

Also awarded in:
2025, 2024, 2023, 2022, 2021, 2020, 2019, 2018, 2017, 2016, 2015, 2014, 2013, 2012, 2011, 2010

2024 Super Lawyers

Also awarded in:
2024, 2023, 2022, 2021, 2020, 2019, 2018, 2017, 2016, 2015, 2014, 2013, 2012, 2011, 2010, 2009, 2008

Certified Civil Trial Law Specialists

7 Certified Civil Trial Law Specialists, Minnesota Bar Association
3 Board Certified Trial Advocates, National Board of Trial Advocacy.

MORE AWARD DETAILS AND RECOGNIZED ATTORNEYS

Subscribe to our Know Your Rights Newsletter

Get the latest insights on health, safety, and legal rights for your family.

SUBSCRIBE

Had an Accident or Injury?
WE CAN HELP!

  • No risk or obligation. We only collect fees if you win.
  • Free review of your options and potential for success.
  • Trusted by more than 65,000 people just like you since 1952.

Call us 24/7 at 1-800-4-RIGHTS (744487)

Or complete the form

Would you recommend us?

We are interested in hearing about your experience with SiebenCarey Personal Injury Law.

Would you mind leaving a review? If so, please take a moment to tell us about your experience and also mention the attorney you worked with. Your feedback helps us to improve our services to you and all clients.

Review on Google Review on Facebook

Was your experience not ideal?

Contact Us Directly

Contact Us

We strive to provide top quality legal and customer service. We're sorry that we didn't meet our own expectations for you.

How can we do better?

Free Know Your Rights Kit

Subscribe to our Know Your Rights Newsletter

Subscribe to receive valuable monthly emails regarding health, safety, and your legal rights.

AUTO ACCIDENTS

  • Car Accidents
  • Motorcycle Accidents
  • Bicycle Accidents
  • Bus Accidents
  • Drunk Driving Accidents
  • Pedestrian Accidents
  • Semi-Truck Accidents
  • SUV Rollover Accidents

PERSONAL INJURY

  • ATV Accidents
  • Boating Accidents
  • Civil Rights Violations
  • Construction Accidents
  • Dog Bites
  • Product Liability
  • Slip, Trip and Fall
  • Snowmobile Accidents
  • Train Accidents
  • Wrongful Death Accidents
  • Medical Malpractice
  • Birth Injuries
  • Hospital Negligence
  • Medication Errors
  • Misdiagnosis
  • Nursing Home Negligence
  • Surgical Complications

WORKERS COMP

  • Construction Accidents
  • Minnesota Work Comp Law Update
  • Occupational Diseases
  • Third Party Claims
  • Workers' Compensation At A Glance

ABOUT US

  • Award Winning Attorneys
  • Blog
  • Certified Investigators
  • Case Studies
  • Community Service
  • Contact Us
  • Minnesota Statute of Limitations
  • Newsletter
  • Verdicts and Settlements

LOCATIONS

Serving all of Minnesota with offices in:

Minneapolis, Minnesota
612-333-4500

Lakeville, Minnesota
952-469-2288

Duluth, Minnesota
218-722-6848

©2024 SiebenCarey
  • Contact Us
  • Español
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
Join Us: